12 Most Overrated Movies of All Time, In response to Reddit

It isn’t mandatory that motion pictures that make it large on the display could be all that. Whereas some motion pictures might have garnered mass acclaim they don’t fare effectively on the Reddit scale. Proper from Titanic to Frozen, a number of the highest-grossing motion pictures don’t get the Reddit seal of approval.

All followers have their laundry checklist of films that they discover overrated, as controversial because the opinion could be, but when there’s one place that homes the strongest opinions it needs to be Reddit. r/AskReddit is stuffed with customers inquiring about probably the most overrated motion pictures of all time. Did the films make it large on the display? Certain, however have been they overrated? Some Redditors agree.

Up to date on June 2, 2023, by Hannah Saab:

Solely time will inform if this yr’s flashiest motion pictures like John Wick: Chapter 4 will go down in historical past as cinematic masterpieces or overrated blockbusters. And, as regular, followers can flip to Reddit to see the shifting opinions and discussions about widespread movies that do not deserve all of the hype.



12 ‘The Biggest Showman’ (2017)

The Greatest Showman Zendaya

Launched in 2017 as Michael Gracey’s directorial debut, The Biggest Showman was a highly-rated musical for its glorious performances, manufacturing, and visuals. The movie is a biographical drama primarily based on the lifetime of P.T. Barnum, an entertainer and creator of the Barnum & Bailey Circus.

Regardless that the movie acquired important acclaim, Redditors have been fast to level out the oversimplification of battle decision within the film – Mcrarburger says “it actually felt like there have been like 8 conflicts within the film they usually all get solved by a music that exhibits up instantly after the battle occurs.” Whereas it is simple to understand the music and the performances, Barnum’s portrayal was unrealistic, and the film glorified him to a sure extent when he was a horrible individual. Reddit consumer Smiffaay very succinctly described it as “meh.”

Watch on Disney+

11 ‘Crash’ (2004)

Matt Dillon and Thandiwe Newton in Crash (2004)

Launched in 2004 and directed by Paul Haggis, Crash was a private ardour piece primarily based on a real incident in Haggis’ life when he was carjacked in Los Angeles. The film was a industrial success and earned over $98 million with a $6.5 million price range.

Redditors, nevertheless, weren’t too pleased with the excessive scores and industrial success of the film. They discovered the portrayal of racism to be slightly simplistic and the ethical pandering to be moderately extreme, which a Redditor describes as “being overwhelmed over the pinnacle with an anvil.” Person W_Herzog_Starship places it throughout as “a screenplay from a excessive schooler.” These echo previous reactions to the film’s Oscar controversy when it discovered itself in scorching water when it beat out Brokeback Mountain.

10 ‘Gravity’ (2013)

Gravity, Ranking the films of Alfonso Cuarón, sandra bullock, astronaut

Very like Avatar, Gravity was one other movie that was touted for its glorious visuals, and when you may have a price range of $100 million, you are likely to go all out on the particular results. Gravity made it large within the theaters revamped $700 million on the field workplace and received 7 Oscars.

Redditors suppose in any other case, with ahx3000 sharing how they “could not stand watching it.” The plot was not very immersive, and plot factors have been subpar at greatest with a couple of loopholes right here and there. Some Reddit customers even went as far as to level out a number of the scientific inaccuracies within the film, with HipToss79 leaving an unflinching remark mentioning how the film “mainly butchered the legal guidelines of physics.” Discuss gravity-defying.

Watch on Max

9 ‘The Irishman’ (2019)

The Irishman
Picture by way of Netflix 

If a film is produced by Martin Scorsese and has a star-studded forged that includes Robert De Niro, Al Pacino, and Joe Pesci you’ll count on that they’d have the motion sequences and the CGI down pat. However The Irishman didn’t stay as much as the Redditors’ scale and was deemed as a largely overrated film.

Regardless that the film used a moderately sophisticated three-rig digital camera system for the Deaging results to return by way of, they didn’t stick the touchdown with that one as Reddit consumer luca_the_heretic known as it “younger face on stooping physique.” The Redditor iTz_Maverick additionally asks how nobody among the many creators “seen how ridiculous [a specific scene] regarded,” which was the tipping level for many viewers. The scene in query is the place Robert De Niro is seen beating up a person, which is a sequence that appears pretty staged and it’s evident that De Niro wasn’t kicking the person in any respect.

Watch on Netflix

8 ‘Fairly Lady’ (1990)

Edward and Vivian from Pretty Woman standing together

A 90s rom-com basic starring Julia Roberts and Richard Gere, Fairly Lady was one of many highest-grossing movies in 1990. Whereas the film was initially meant to be a darkish plot about courses and intercourse work, it was redefined as a tacky rom-com the place the intercourse employee with a coronary heart of gold falls in love with the wealthy businessman.

Within the true Reddit spirit, consumer jenel2583 sarcastically commented concerning the unlikely plot of the movie and the way items conveniently fell into place, giving a hilarious criticism within the type of an outline of the story: “Julia Roberts as your typical drop-dead-gorgeous streetwalker with no discernible dependancy or psychological well being issues and a coronary heart of gold, and Richard Gere because the stunningly good-looking millionaire who’s laborious up for a date. Lovely!” Others believed that it was nothing greater than a Cinderella Story and that the one motive the film was so extremely rated was due to Julia Roberts.

7 ‘The Pocket book’ (2004)

The-Notebook rachel mcadams ryan gosling
Picture by way of New Line

Each 2004 romance fanatic’s bible was The Pocket book. Everybody in some unspecified time in the future needed to take a web page out of Ryan Gosling’s ebook of attraction and relive the enduring scene within the rain. However as extensively talked about because it was, Reddit agrees that it may need been a tad overrated.

Reddit consumer lovebugblues talked about that there was no chemistry or romance between the 2, describing the movie as a “horrible film with no precise romance.” Some may name it love, however Redditors known as it a film that includes a poisonous and dysfunctional relationship between the protagonists that was doomed to fail.

6 ‘Titanic’ (1997)

Leonardo DiCaprio as Jack looking at Kate Winslet as Rose in Titanic
Picture by way of twentieth Century Fox

One other field workplace hit by James Cameron, Titanic turned the epitome of romance and tragedy when it got here out in 1997. The industrial success of the film was on such a big scale that it was the primary movie to succeed in the billion-dollar mark earlier than Cameron’s Avatar overtook it in 2010. A 3D model of the Titanic was additionally launched in 2012 to mark the centennial of the ship sinking, which added a couple of further bucks to the movie’s worth.

However that doesn’t cease the folks of Reddit, who deemed it a extremely overrated movie. One Redditor believes it would not deserve all of the hype, saying “it’s good however there’s a variety of higher motion pictures.” In true James Cameron vogue, the visuals have been phenomenal and stored the viewers captivated, however Redditors felt the plot was skinny. And if the memes are something to go by, viewers do suppose there was sufficient house for jack on the floorboard.

Watch on Paramount+

5 ‘Grease’ (1978)

Picture by way of Paramount

Grease was some of the iconic rom-com musicals of the 70s, and it even turned the highest-grossing musical on the time. The summer time romance between Olivia Newton-John and John Travolta was a love story for the ages with a soundtrack to recollect.

However regardless of the excessive scores and industrial success, Reddit customers argue that it stays one of many extra overrated movies to at the present time. Redditors agree that the film didn’t age effectively, with the consumer PokemonMaster619 detailing how they “actually don’t care about Grease as a film or perhaps a story, per se. It’s only a primary highschool romance story.” One other Reddit consumer says “it is not the perfect film or musical of all time, the songs are silly and tacky” and underscores how the characters who’re supposedly teenagers have been performed by 30-year-olds (which does maintain since Olivia Newton-John was 30 years previous when she performed Sandy Olsson and Stockard Channing was 33 when she performed Betty Rizzo).

4 ‘Chicken Field’ (2018)

bird box sandra bullock top 10 most watched netflix movies

Chicken Field is a post-apocalyptic horror thriller set in a world the place a mysterious drive has pushed survivors into hiding, as seeing the terrifying entities instantly causes them to die. Within the midst of the chaos, a lady and her kids search sanctuary and expertise horrific occasions alongside the best way.

A Netflix hit, Chicken Field reached 45 million viewers inside the first week of its premiere, cementing it as one of many platform’s hottest motion pictures. It impressed numerous memes and challenges, which did not sit proper with the consumer BalrogSlayer00, who thought the web’s obsession with the movie “was dangerous.”

Watch on Netflix

3 ‘The Starvation Video games’ (2012)

Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss in The Hunger Games (2012)
Picture by way of Lionsgate

The 2012 dystopian blockbuster that signaled the start of a large franchise, The Starvation Video games was primarily based on the eponymous 2008 novel by Suzanne Collins. It is set in a future the place representatives from numerous districts are compelled to compete in a nationally televised occasion, which is basically a sport to the loss of life.

In a thread about probably the most overrated motion pictures of all time, Lady_Warhead factors out how the movie “by no means actually explored the depth […] that was within the books, it very a lot turned from a subpar exploration of utmost capitalist exploits and psychological sickness to a love triangle with slightly little bit of violence and possibly Katniss being unhappy from time to time.”

Watch on Hulu

2 ‘Frozen’ (2013)

Elsa singing in Frozen (2013)
Picture by way of Disney

The very best-grossing movie of 2013, Frozen was all the craze that yr and set a powerful precedent for upcoming animated Disney movies. The movie was in all places and was closely commercialized, and the soundtrack had turn out to be a winter staple.

However Redditors could not appear to… let it go. Whereas it could have been the highest-grossing movie, Reddit consumer RockednRolled mentions that the movie “doesn’t even come near the OG Disney animated motion pictures.” Regardless that the movie is focused at kids, some customers like awesome_van known as the plot “utterly nonsensical” and compelled a lot in order that it didn’t warrant a sequel, going as far as to assert that total, “Frozen is a multitude.”

Watch on Disney+

1 ‘Avatar’ (2009)


Avatar was some of the technologically superior motion pictures of its time and confirmed the world what nice 3D film design might do. James Cameron set the stage for a lot of extra 3D motion pictures to return. With a whopping price range of $237 million, you wouldn’t count on something lower than a masterpiece.

The film is a looker and most scenes look unreal in IMAX, however the storyline simply doesn’t minimize it for Reddit. Nice visuals apart, the plot doesn’t stay as much as the identical requirements. Reddit consumer DramaticChoice4 described the plot as “fairly cliché” and famous that “folks watch it principally for the visuals.” One other Redditor takes it even additional by detailing how “the motion wasn’t good, the characterization and world constructing was pathetic, and other than the unimaginable CGI and artwork route (not all of it, although), it is a mediocre movie.”

Watch on Disney+

NEXT: A Historical past of the Highest-Grossing Movie of All Time